Easy-to-make pumpkin butter is the perfect fall condiment. Spread it on everything from pancakes to dinner rolls!

By Jessica Formicola from Savory Experiments
Updated August 18, 2018

Pumpkin Butter

Autumn has arrived and with it comes the changing of colors, cozy sweaters, and my favorite treat: pumpkin butter. Lattes, breakfasts, salads, entrees, desserts, and snacks are dramatically improved by this pumpkin butter. The name pumpkin butter is slightly deceiving, since it doesn't actually contain butter, nor is it the consistency of butter. More like apple sauce, it is a simmered mixture of pumpkin puree, spices, and sugar. The end result is a crave-able sweet spread that will soon be your favorite condiment.

When your award-winning pumpkin butter is complete, slather it on pancakes, toast, scones, and waffles, or spread it over roasted veggies. It also tastes good in risotto or on grilled chicken or fish. It is my go-to hostess gift for the holidays. I purchase a set of glass bottles, festive string, and colorful labels and voila, a homemade gift.

More Halloween Treat Ideas

Tools for Blending

Spice blends can vary, but most are a standard mix of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice, and cloves. Sugars also vary, but my favorite blend is brown sugar and maple syrup, for an earthy and rustic sweetness. Some prepare pumpkin butter in a slow cooker but, in all honesty, a saucepan on simmer will do the trick in just an hour. While I prefer my pumpkin butter to have some body, others want a smooth consistency achieved by a quick whirl in the food processor.

Recipe for Creamy Pumpkin Butter

Yields: 2-1/2 cups



  1. Place all ingredients in a heavy bottom sauce pan. Heat over medium-low until bubbling.
  2. Stir well and reduce heat to low. Continue to stir and simmer for an hour.
  3. Mixture will have some texture; place in a food processor to make it smooth if desired.

Our Favorite Pumpkin Recipes


Be the first to comment!