7 Crusts That Will Make Your Pie a Blue Ribbon Winner

We've got you covered from chocolate to gluten-free.
Tastes of Lizzy T

Move over turkey! We all know pie is the real boss this fall season. To make sure you have the best pie at the party, we found the most unique, tasty pie crust recipes on the internet. Seriously, our mouths are watering just thinking about these! Check out our seven favorites below:

1. Cinnamon Pie Crust


Spice up the season this year with cinnamon pie crust. This incredibly easy recipe is simple to make and adds a zing of flavor to your favorite pies. We recommend using this crust with traditional pumpkin pie or your favorite pecan pie.

Get the recipe from McCormick

2. Oreo Pie Crust

Love To Be In The Kitchen

They say your pie is only as good as the crust, so why not sit your pie on a bed of your favorite cookies? This is a great pie crust to make with the kids, too. Just watch them closely. They will be sneaking crumbs every time you turn around!

Get the recipe from Love To Be In The Kitchen

3. All-Butter Pie Crust

Sugar Apron

You will have a hard time trying to find a flakier or lighter crust than this homemade all-butter pie crust. Of course, there is more than just one ingredient, but butter really steals the spotlight in this recipe. The calories don't count during the holidays, right?

Get the recipe from Sugar Apron

4. Nilla Wafer Crust

Mom On Time Out

We love Nilla Wafers for their simple, timeless flavor that makes them so versatile for desserts. The latest use is to put them in a food processor and crumble them up for a yummy, interesting pie crust. Just imagine how great this would be with key lime pie!

Get the recipe from Mom On Time Out

5. Easy Oatmeal Pie Crust

Tastes of Lizzy T

Can't decide if you want an oatmeal cookie or a traditional pie? Get both with this oatmeal pie crust! This flavorful pie base will be the most memorable dessert at your holiday party thanks to the yummy oats and sweet brown sugar.

Get the recipe from Tastes of Lizzy T

6. Gluten-Free Cheerios Crust

Betty Crocker

Accommodate your gluten-free guests without sacrificing flavor with this pie crust made from Honey Nut Cheerios! We love this recipe because it's an unexpected twist on a nostalgic snack we all love.

Get the recipe from Betty Crocker

7. Chocolate Pie Crust

Simply Scratch

When in doubt, choose chocolate. This rich, chocolatey option is the best way to make your favorite pie even better. Baking it in a delicate tart pan will make your crust small enough to not overpower the flavor of the pie. We can't wait to try it!

Get the recipe from Simply Scratch


Be the first to comment!

Better Homes & Gardens may receive compensation when you click through and purchase from links contained on this website.