Must-Know Pros and Cons of Butcher-Block Countertops

Find out if butcher-block countertops are right for you with our comprehensive guide to the pros and cons of the durable and affordable countertop material.

Made from straight cuts of wood that are glued together into slabs, butcher block makes a sturdy, attractive countertop. Butcher block is most commonly made from maple, which is hard and has a clear grain, but it can be crafted from any wood. The material has rustic warmth and classic appeal that complements cozy country, cottage, and traditional kitchens. It can also add unexpected contrast to a stark, modern space. Learn about the pros and cons of this popular kitchen countertop material, the average price of butcher block, and how to extend its lifespan with proper maintenance and upkeep.

black white kitchen modern minimalist butcher block counter range
Edmund Barr

Benefits of Butcher-Block Countertops

Butcher-block countertops have a long history and for good reason. If maintained properly, wood is durable and develops a deep patina over time. Butcher block tends to show nicks and scratches for a shopworn look, but if you don't like the wear and tear, you can lightly sand out flaws and re-oil the surface to restore it. If you want to use your countertop as a cutting surface, choose an unsealed, oil-finished product designed for food preparation. With permeable sealants, wood has natural antibacterial properties that make it ideal for cutting.

Butcher-Block Pros: Durable; attractive finish; easy to repair and restore; naturally antibacterial.

Disadvantages of Butcher Block

Wood countertops aren't without faults. Most notably, water is potentially hazardous to wood, so unsealed butcher block isn't recommended near a sink. Wood contracts and expands when exposed to moisture, which can lead to irreparable warping, discoloration, or rot. Butcher-block counters must be oiled often to fill in scratches and protect the surface, and they also need frequent disinfecting to prevent bacteria. Spills must be cleaned immediately to avoid stains. Wood counters are not heat-resistant, and extreme dryness can cause cracking, so it's important to use pads or trivets with hot pans.

Cons of Butcher Block: Prone to water damage and stains; require frequent oiling and disinfecting; not heat-resistant; can be expensive.

Eco-friendly countertop
Erik Bell

Cost of Butcher-Block Countertops

While maple countertops can be less than half the cost of natural stone, higher-quality custom butcher block can be as expensive as granite. According to data from HomeAdvisor, butcher-block countertops cost $40 to $100 per square foot on average.

Butcher-Block Maintenance and Cleaning

Maintained properly, butcher-block countertops can last a very long time. It's important to check the manufacturer's care recommendations before cleaning or repairing countertops. In general, caring for wood counters starts with routine cleaning, which is as simple as using mild soap or vinegar and water every time you use the surface. This step is also important to prevent contamination issues that can happen with porous wood.

It's also important to re-oil the counters at least every six months with food-safe mineral oil. If the counter gets chipped, scratched, or burned, lightly sand the area with fine sandpaper and then reapply oil. To get all the benefits of butcher-block countertops without the potential problems, some homeowners limit the material to a work island or other smaller surface.

Was this page helpful?
Related Articles