For information on other reputable home warranty providers, read our article on the best home warranty companies in the industry.
In this article:
Choice Home Warranty offers two comprehensive plan options: a Basic plan and a Total plan. The company’s Basic plan covers 14 different appliances and systems, while the company’s Total plan covers everything in the Basic plan, plus coverage for a dryer, washer, refrigerator, and air conditioning system.
Choice Home Warranty also offers nine optional add-ons:
Below we break down the specific items covered by the company’s two coverage plans.
The Basic Plan covers the following:
The Total Plan covers everything in the Basic Plan, plus:
American Home Shield offers three coverage plans to homeowners: an Appliances plan, Systems plan, and a Combo plan. The Appliances plan covers essential home appliances, the Systems plan protects major home systems, and the Combo plan provides coverage for 21 systems and appliances.
American Home Shield also offers five optional add-ons:
Below we outline the items covered under each American Home Shield plan.
The Appliances Plan covers:
The Systems Plan covers:
The Combo Plan combines all the coverage of the Appliances and Systems Plans.
American Home Shield monthly premiums and service fees are slightly more expensive than what Choice Home Warranty offers. View the tables below for the monthly premium and service fee costs for both of these companies.
Note: Optional add-on pricing for these two providers depends on the covered item you add to your plan. Homeowners can expect to add about $40 to $180 to their annual home warranty cost for each optional add-on they include with their coverage.
Both Choice Home Warranty and American Home Shield received positive ratings from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), but only American Home Shield is accredited by the organization.
Note: Choice Home Warranty is currently involved with a lawsuit with the Arizona Attorney General’s Office that alleges that the company used false advertising and misled customers. Choice resolved a similar lawsuit in 2015 with the New Jersey Attorney General and agreed to pay a fine and hire an independent compliance monitoring company to supervise its advertising practices.
To avoid claims being denied, we recommend carefully reading through the terms and conditions of your sample contract before signing up for a home warranty and reaching out to your provider’s customer service department if you have any questions.
Choice Home Warranty and American Home Shield are two of the top home warranty companies in the industry because of their comprehensive coverage plans and affordable pricing. Our review team named Choice Home Warranty as best for older homes because it covers appliances and systems regardless of their age, and we named American Home Shield as the best overall home warranty provider because of its variety of coverage plan offerings and breadth of covered items within each plan.
We recommend Choice Home Warranty for homeowners who are on a budget or want basic home warranty coverage, and we recommend American Home Shield for homeowners seeking a wider variety of coverage options and are willing to pay for the most comprehensive coverage.
If you're not sure if Choice Home Warranty or American Home Shield is right for you, we named Select Home Warranty as the best home warranty company for budget shoppers because it offers three coverage plans for under $40 per month and a low $75 service fee.
To get a free quote from Select Home Warranty, call 888-370-3956 or complete this form.
American Home Shield and Choice Home Warranty are two of the best home warranty companies in the industry for their comprehensive plans and relatively affordable pricing. Our review team recommends Choice Home Warranty as the best for older homes because it covers appliances and systems of all ages. We recommend American Home Shield as the best home warranty company overall because of its stellar coverage plans and customizable coverage options.
A home warranty plan protects homeowners from having to pay for unexpected, expensive repairs or replacements on major home systems and appliances. Instead of paying hundreds to thousands of dollars out-of-pocket, homeowners with a home warranty plan pay a relatively small monthly premium and a service call fee every time a repair or replacement is needed.
Additionally, having a home warranty plan can prevent you from spending time looking for a trusted contractor in your area, as most companies have a network of thousands of licensed technicians to complete repairs and replacements.
The waiting period for Choice Home Warranty and American Home Shield is 30 days, which means that your coverage won’t start until 30 days after you sign your service contract with your chosen home warranty company.
American Home Shield and Choice Home Warranty both provide 24/7 customer service.
American Home Shield’s Appliances plan and Combo plan cover a washer and dryer, and Choice Home Warranty’s Total plan covers a washer and dryer.
Our review team named the following providers as the top five home warranty companies in the industry: