Creative Desserts from Leftover Halloween Candy

Peeking Monster cupcake
From spooky sweets to everyday treats, our easy recipes show you how to use leftover goodies to create dazzling desserts.

Creepy Crawlers

Black licorice, M&Ms, and Skittles turn these easy cookie sandwiches into creepy sweets. To save time, use store-bought cookies and vanilla frosting.

Mr. Pearly Whites

Kids love this spooky treat, which features a Hostess cupcake, Fruit Roll-Ups, and assorted candies.

Spiced Mice

These creepy cookies are another kid favorite. Leftover chocolate candies make the eyes and nose, while crunchy chow mein noodles make cute curly tails.

Monster Mouths

This yummy treat is the perfect after-school snack. All you need are apples, peanut butter, and candy corn.

Funny Frog

With store-bought cupcakes and colorful chocolate candies, this spooky frog-inspired treat is a snap to make.

To make it, follow these steps:

1. Cut a Hostess Ho Ho in half and place on top of a frosted cupcake.
2. Use melted chocolate to adhere blue mini M&Ms to each piece of Ho Ho for eyes.
3. Place green mini M&Ms in cupcake frosting covering cupcake.
4. Use fruit roll-ups or fruit leather to make strands of hair and a tongue.

Silly Popcorn Treats

Put your leftover gummy worms and candy corn to good use by whipping up a batch of mini popcorn balls.

Frankenstein

If you have lots of leftover candy, this friendly Frankenstein treat is the way to go. You can make it with almost anything; we like using Tootsie Rolls, M&Ms, and Smarties.

Wicked Witch's Hat

You can use almost any Halloween candy to decorate this treat "witch"-ever way you want. The base is popcorn, creating a salty-sweet snack that's hard to resist.

Howling Werewolf

This hair-raising cupcake is a frightfully fabulous treat for Halloween parties.

To create your own Howling Werewolf cupcake:

1. Start with frosted store-bought or homemade cupcakes.
2. Use pieces of shredded wheat to create hair, beard, and whiskers.
3. Press 2 mini red M&M's into the cupcake for eyes.
4. Make a dot on each mini red M&M for the pupils.
5. Press 2 candy corn pieces on either side of the eyes for ears.
6. Tear off a small piece of black licorice for the nose.
7. Use white frosting to make the mouth.
8. Press 2 frosted sunflower kernels on each side of the mouth for fangs.

Banana Boo Bars

Use Halloween candies to create spooky patterns on these easy-to-make bar cookies.

Burnt Sugar Candy Bar Cake

Your favorite candy bars and a browned-butter cream cheese frosting top luscious cake. Cooking the sugar until it's caramelized gives the cake a rich, distinct flavor.

Brownie Pizza

This easy dessert pizza is chocolaty, crunchy, gooey, and delicious. Add toasted marshmallows to the mix for sticky-sweet goodness.

Malted Milk Ball Cookies

Malted milk balls make this delicious cookie recipe even harder to resist.

Peanut Butter and Candy Cookies

These tender peanut butter cookies feature a delightful chocolaty surprise. If miniature candy bars aren't available, cut regular-size bars into 1-inch squares.

Candy-Bar Bars

No one will ever guess that these rich cookies start with a simple cake mix. Your favorite candy bar makes a quick and easy topping.

Share the gallery



Better Homes & Gardens may receive compensation when you click through and purchase from links contained on this website.