Cheesecake

Rich, decadent, and creamy, cheesecake is a dessert favored by many. Order a delicious cheesecake online in varieties including original, red velvet cheesecake, pumpkin cheesecake, chocolate marble cheesecake, New York cheesecake, individual cheesecakes, cheesecake samplers, and more.

Refine By
Duncan Hines
$21.84

Today the Duncan Hines product line offers over 80 different sweet baked-good mixes ranging from cakes and brownies to muffins and... cookies, as well as frosting and ready-to-bake brownies. With a relentless commitment to quality, every product and recipe is developed in celebration of Duncan Hines’ inventive spirit and passion for baking. With so many products to choose from, you are sure to find plenty of new and old favorites that will keep your sweet tooth satisfied. read more

Chocolate Covered Company
$38.99

Gourmet all-purpose gift box with sweet treats. Miniature cheesecakes drizzled in Belgian chocolate. Available in your choice of s...izes. Includes milk, dark, and white chocolate. The Gourmet Cheesecake Pops Gift Box is a spectacular way to show you care. Perfect for any special occasion, each miniature cheesecake has been covered and drizzled artfully with exquisite imported Belgian chocolate. This box includes an assortment of white, milk, and dark that is sure to make anyone's mouth water. Choose your number of pops. All come packaged in a secure foam-like casing within an elegant gift box. They're double-reinforced with a thick layer of high-density foam around the shipping box. A chemical-free ice pack keeps everything fresh and cool. Refrigerate or open immediately and enjoy!Please note that for this item, future delivery is available, which lets you select a specific date for delivery, so your gift arrives at the perfect time. Call 800-461-6836 for assistance with delivery options.About Chocolate Covered Company, Inc.Based in Southern California, Chocolate Covered Company is dedicated to providing heavenly treats that satisfy your sweet tooth every time. Its unique and delicate berry creations are hand-dipped to perfection using the finest imported chocolate. This Intimate Chocolate Experience is backed by excellent customer service as well as creative design and careful packaging. This ensures that your gift remains secure and fresh while in transit.Because this product is perishable, it is available only with Next Day Air delivery. Please note that whichever delivery method you select, it will ship with Next Day Air. Size: 12 Cheesecake Pops. read more

Omaha Steaks
$24.99 $13.99

Now anytime is Cheesecake time - because you can have one all to yourself! Made with rich cream cheese and genuine sour cream, our... dreamy smooth Individual NY Cheesecakes are both creamy and tangy. A buttery graham cracker crust is the final touch for these thaw-and-serve slices of heaven. Don't miss out, have these in your freezer for those times when your sophisticated sweet tooth won't be denied! (Oh, and they're great for guests, family dinners and even brunches!) read more

Omaha Steaks
$24.99 $13.99

Ever wish for a variety of cheesecake flavors to serve a small group? Here's a delicious option: The Individual Cheesecake Sampler...! These four flavors will tantalize your taste buds with a rich, smooth, cream-cheese texture. And the flavors? Fabulous! Turtle offers caramel, pecans and chocolate. Oreo® of course with real Oreo® bits and chocolate cookie crust. Tangy Raspberry Swirl has real raspberry puree to tweak your senses. And a customer favorite, sublime New York Cheesecake. Perfect for a buffet, a brunch or. a treat just for you! read more

Cheesecake City
$76.00

Cheesecake sampler offers eight different flavors. Two slices of each flavor: white chocolate pistachio, blueberry swirl, cappucci...no, amaretto, chocolate fudge, New York-style, raspberry swirl, and chocolate chip. Made with all-natural ingredients. Ships frozen; simply thaw and serve. 4 lbs. 10"Dia. 16 slices total. read more

$58.00

ONLYATNM Only Here. Only Ours. Exclusively for You. Gluten free. Manufactured in a dedicated gluten-free facility. Blood orange wh...ite chocolate silk New York cheesecake batter swirled with raspberry puree throughout on a flourless semi-sweet chocolate truffle cake. Ships frozen. Store in freezer until ready to serve. Thaw in refrigerator for 2 hours or overnight, then serve. 6"Dia. Serves 10. Made in the USA. read more

Annie Pie's Bakery
$60.00

Rich flavor of creme brulee and its traditional finish of caramelized sugar topping. Arrives partially frozen; remove collar befor...e thawing. Thaw overnight in refrigerator before serving. If quick thawing is required, leave out at room temperature for 30-60 minutes. Keeps 3-5 days in refrigerator; up to six months frozen. 7"Dia. Serves 8-10. read more

Sweet Lady Jane
$60.00

Made with fresh raspberries and decorated with a raspberry swirl on top. Graham cracker crust. Ships frozen. Thaw in refrigerator ...1-2 hours. Serve cold. 9"Dia. x 2.5"T. Serves 12-16. Made in the USA. read more

$175.00

Only at NM: Only Here. Only Ours. Exclusively for You. A triple mocha cheesecake on a shortbread crust encased in dark and white c...hocolate "paper" (not fondant). Tied with a luscious, edible, satiny white chocolate ribbon and bow edged with gold. Refrigerate upon arrival; good for eight days. 6"Sq. x 4"T. Serves 10-12. Made in the USA. read more

$52.00

Precut sampler includes 16 slices in four delicious flavorsstrawberry, cherry, blueberry, and pineapple. Fruit garnish not include...d. Arrives at least partially frozen. Thaw overnight in refrigerator or at room temperature for 2-3 hours, and serve. Keeps 3-5 days in refrigerator or up to six months frozen. 10"Dia. Serves 16. Made in the USA. read more

Sweet Lady Jane
$60.00

Old-fashioned New York-style cheesecake with a touch of lemon and orange rind. Enveloped in an all-butter crust. Ships frozen. Tha...w in refrigerator for 1-2 hours. Serve cold. 9"Dia. x 2.5"T. Serves 12-16. Made in the USA. read more

Omaha Steaks
$39.99 $19.99

Premium ingredients make this decadent cheesecake delicious; its impressive 3-inch height makes it a memorable centerpiece. Perfec...tly pre-baked for you for the perfect richness, creaminess, and tang atop a thick Graham cracker crust, this New York-style cheesecake makes serving the perfect dessert easy. Simply thaw and serve. Serves 8. read more

$52.00

Precut sampler includes 16 slices in four delicious flavorsstrawberry, cherry, blueberry, and pineapple. Fruit garnish not include...d. Arrives at least partially frozen. Thaw overnight in refrigerator or at room temperature for 2-3 hours, and serve. Keeps 3-5 days in refrigerator or up to six months frozen. 10"Dia. Serves 16. Made in the USA. read more

Sweet Lady Jane
$60.00

Made with fresh raspberries and decorated with a raspberry swirl on top. Graham cracker crust. Ships frozen. Thaw in refrigerator ...1-2 hours. Serve cold. 9"Dia. x 2.5"T. Serves 12-16. Made in the USA. read more

Sweet Lady Jane
$60.00

Old-fashioned New York-style cheesecake with a touch of lemon and orange rind. Enveloped in an all-butter crust. Ships frozen. Tha...w in refrigerator for 1-2 hours. Serve cold. 9"Dia. x 2.5"T. Serves 12-16. Made in the USA. read more

Shari's Berries
$49.98

Make It Their Best Birthday Ever, With A Duo Of Unforgettable Gifts. First, They'll Enjoy Rich, Bite-Sized Birthday Cake Truffles ...In An Assortment Of Gourmet Flavors. Tucked Into An Artfully Decorated Box, Each Cake Truffle Hides A Fun And Festive Hidden Message, Like Happy Birthday And You Don't Look A Day Over Fabulous. To Top Off The Surprise, They'll Also Receive A Trio Of Decadent Mini Cheesecakes That Have Been Dipped In Dark Chocolate And Topped With White Chocolate Shavings, Nuts And Marshmallows. read more

Chicago Metallic
$19.95

Mini Cheesecake Pan 12 Cavity You love cheesecake, but not the mess involved with baking it. Problem solved! This pan co...mes with removable bottoms so each mini cheesecake, or any baking treat, slides right out. What You Get (1) 13-3/4"L x 10-1/2"H x 1-1/2"W mini cheesecake pan with (12) 2" x 1-1/4" cavities read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Cherry Cheesecake Grab a fork and dive into a slice of pure heaven with David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. C...herry Cheesecake. The only way to make David's plain New York cheesecake better was to add a generous helping of cherry preserves on top, delivering a tantalizing taste that'll have you dreaming of more. This 4-1/4 lb. cheesecake is pre-sliced for your convenience and serves 14. What You Get 4-1/4 lb. Cherry Cheesecake Good to Know read more

David's Cookies
$59.95

David's Cookies New York-Style Cheesecake 2-pack  It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you...'re simply craving something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get (2) 68 oz. New York-style cheesecakes Good to Know Contains soy, wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

Tony Little
$59.95

Tony Little Gourmet Protein Sensations Cheesecakes 10-pack Craving something sweet and creamy? These individually packed mini stra...wberry cheesecakes are smooth and delicious, but also high in protein, low in sodium and made with a sugar substitute. Treat yourself to a little something scrumptious. What You Get (10) 4.5 oz. High protein strawberry cheesecakes Good to Know Contains eggs and milk. May contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4.25 lb. Creme Brulee Cheesecake It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're si...mply craving something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 4.25 lb. creme brulee cheesecake Good to Know Contains wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

Tony Little
$59.95

Tony Little Protein Sensations 10-count Cheesecakes Craving something sweet and creamy? These individually packed mini cheesecakes... are smooth and delicious, but also high in protein, low in sodium and made with a sugar substitute. So treat yourself to a little something scrumptious. What You Get (2) 4.5 oz. traditional New York cheesecakes (4) 4.5 oz. chocolate marble cheesecakes (4) 4.5 oz. strawberry cheesecakes Good to Know Contains eggs, soy and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$59.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. creme brulee cheesecake Good to Know Contains soy, wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. blueberry cheesecake Good to Know Contains soy, wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

Tony Little
$59.95

Tony Little Protein Sensations 10-count Cheesecakes Craving something sweet and creamy? These individually packed mini cheesecakes... are smooth and delicious, but also high in protein, low in sodium and made with a sugar substitute. So treat yourself to a little something scrumptious. What You Get (5) 4.5 oz. traditional New York cheesecakes (5) 4.5 oz. chocolate marble cheesecakes Good to Know  Contains eggs and milk. May contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. New York Cheesecake As traditional as Mom's apple pie and the classic black dress, David'...s Cookies 4-1/4 lb. New York Cheesecake will thrill the most finicky of dessert purists. Embellish a slice with fresh fruit, bits of peppermint candy, chocolate shavings or a drizzle of liqueur to step it up a notch. What You Get 4-1/4 lb. New York Cheesecake Good to Know read more

David's Cookies
$26.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Triple Chocolate Cheesecake Imagine rich milk chocolate over a silky chocolate cheesecake perched on a b...ase of devil's food cake. It's David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Triple Chocolate Cheesecake. Have some on hand to satisfy even the fiercest chocolaholic. What You Get 4-1/4 lb. Triple Chocolate Cheesecake Good to Know read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. cookies 'n cream cheesecake Good to Know Contains soy, wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$59.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. chocolate caramel pecan cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. Strawberry cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 10" Strawberry Cheesecake It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply cr...aving something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. strawberry cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Blueberry Cheesecake Pump up your cheesecake with fruit! David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Blueberry Cheese...cake takes its classic New York cheesecake one step closer to nirvana with a generous helping of sweet, fruity blueberries. What a way to introduce fruit into your diet! What You Get Blueberry Cheesecake  Good to Know This product may contain or come into contact with milk, nuts and peanuts and should be avoided by persons with allergies to these foods. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Pineapple Cheesecake Pump up your cheesecake with fruit! David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Pineap...ple Cheesecake takes its classic New York cheesecake one step closer to nirvana with a generous helping of lip-smacking pineapple. What a way to introduce fruit into your diet! What You Get Pineapple Cheesecake Good to Know This product may contain or come into contact with milk, nuts and peanuts and should be avoided by persons with allergies to these foods. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Chocolate Caramel Pecan Cheesecake Leave the turtle behind and hop quick as a bunny for this D...avid's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Chocolate Caramel Pecan Cheesecake. Each sinfully delicious piece delights your palette with chewy clumps of milk chocolate and caramel-drenched pecans melded with rich and creamy cheesecake anchored by a base of devil's food cake. What You Get 4-1/4 lb. Chocolate Caramel Pecan Cheesecake Good to Know read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. Amaretto cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 10" Amaretto Cheesecake It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply crav...ing something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. amaretto cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies Marble Truffle Cheesecake Why choose between chocolate and cheesecake when you don't have to? The best of both wor...lds, this delectable cake combines half flourless chocolate truffle cake and half flourless cheesecake. Smooth, dense and creamy, it's sinfully rich and delicious. You can have it all. What You Get 56 oz. marble truffle cheesecake Good to Know Contains eggs, milk, soy and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

Tony Little
$59.95

Tony Little Protein Sensations 10-count Traditional New York Cheesecakes Craving something sweet and creamy? These individual...ly packed mini cheesecakes are smooth and delicious, but also high in protein, low in sodium and made with a sugar substitute. So treat yourself to a little something scrumptious. What You Get (10) 4.5 oz. traditional New York cheesecakes Good to Know Contains eggs and milk. May contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

Tony Little
$59.95

Tony Little Protein Sensations 10-count Chocolate Marble Cheesecakes Craving something sweet and creamy? These individually packed... mini cheesecakes are smooth and delicious, but also high in protein, low in sodium and made with a sugar substitute. So treat yourself to a little something scrumptious. What You Get (10) 4.5 oz. chocolate marble cheesecakes Good to Know Contains eggs and milk. May contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. Pineapple cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 4-1/4 lb. Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Put a smile on everyone's face with a festive David's Cookies 4-1.../4 lb. Cookies and Cream Cheesecake. Better than a mix-in, this rich cheesecake is brimming with crumbled chocolate and cream cookies, not only on the top, but throughout the tall cake. The chocolate crumble continues to the crust—another David's specialty. What You Get 4-1/4 lb. Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Good to Know This product may contain or come into contact with milk, nuts and peanuts and should be avoided by persons with allergies to these foods. read more

David's Cookies
$59.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. triple chocolate cheesecake Good to Know Contains soy, wheat, eggs and milk and may contain tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$69.95

David's Cookies Cheesecake 2-pack It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply craving so...mething sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. New York-style cheesecake 68 oz. Black forest cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 10" Carrot Cheesecake It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply cravin...g something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. carrot cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

David's Cookies
$39.95

David's Cookies 10" Black Forest Cheesecake It's been a long day. Or your best friend is coming over for coffee. Or you're simply ...craving something sweet on movie night. There's always a good reason to indulge in rich, creamy cheesecake, especially when it's from David's. What You Get 68 oz. black forest cheesecake Good to Know Contains or may contain soy, wheat, eggs, milk, tree nuts and peanuts. read more

This item has been added to your list

This item has been added to your sale alerts