Refine By

Baking and Cookie Sheets Buying Guide

A batch of warm homemade cookies is a sure hit with family and friends. Know that the baking or cookie sheets you use can affect the results of your fresh-baked goodies. Cookie sheets come in several materials, including metal, aluminum, aluminized steel, and more, and they range in quality as well as price.

Types of Baking and Cookie Sheets

Types of Baking and Cookie Sheets

The terms baking sheet and cookie sheet are really the same. They are flat pans that allow heat to circulate around the cookies and make for easy removal. The type of material and finish you choose for cookie sheets affects the final product. Shiny bakeware reflects heat, slowing the browning process; dark- and dull-finish bakeware absorbs more heat, which increases browning.

Metal

Cookie sheets are commonly made of tin, aluminum, aluminized steel, and other metals. Construction ranges from single-ply tin to heavy-duty pans composed of multiple layers with an aluminum core.

shop Metal
Cuisinart
$23.95

The Cuisinart SMB-17BS 17 in. Baking Sheet provides a sleek design and easy-grip silicone handles to bring style and convenience t...o your kitchen. Contoured for standard oven mitts, two side grips make removing delicious sweets and homemade breads from... read more

Cuisinart
$18.35

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Non-Stick Bakeware is ideal for today's cooks. The full line is constructed of Heavy-gauge aluminized ste...el to provide even heat distribution and consistent baking results. The Non-Stick interior and exterior ensure easy food... read more

Nordic Ware
$30.87

4-Piece Baking Set includes quarter sheet and half sheet, each with its own plastic lid. Baking professionals know that the secret... to evenly baked cakes, bars and cookies is to cook with aluminum bakeware. Aluminum is widely known for its excellent... read more

Range Kleen
$5.84

Range Kleen Non-Stick Petite Baking Sheet is a unique compact Petite Bakeware piece that can be used with toasters or countertop o...vens. This Pan is designed for all your baking needs and perfect for one or two servings. It is also a part of item BW5... read more

Finish

Cookies bake more evenly on light- to medium-color cookie sheets, whether the sheets are shiny or nonstick. When baked on dark sheets, cookie bottoms tend to overbrown.

shop Finish
Mrs. Fields
$8.99

Find Bakeware And Ovenware at Target.com! If there's ever someone to trust with your cookies, it's Mrs. Fields! The Mrs. Fields Co...okie Sheet evenly bakes cookies every time.Use your favorite homemade recipe or pick up a mix at the market. read more

Mrs. Fields
$8.99

Find Bakeware And Ovenware at Target.com! If there's ever someone to trust with your cookies, it's Mrs. Fields! The Mrs. Fields Co...okie Sheet evenly bakes cookies every time.Use your favorite homemade recipe or pick up a mix at the market. read more

360 Cookware
$113.99

360 Cookware A012-CS 360 Cookware's cookie/baking sheets are arguably the best in the world. Experience even heating from corner t...o corner and bake batches in less time. This medium sized baking sheet is perfect for appetizers and quick hors d'oeuvres and fits snugly into most countertop toaster ovens. Features: -Even heating.-Heirloom quality.-Saves energy and time.-Cladded 3 ply construction.-Made in the USA.-Product Type: Baking Sheet.-Color: Stainless Steel.-Distressed: No.-Powder Coated Finish: No.-Gloss Finish: No.-Material: Steel -Material Details: Stainless Steel..-Non-Toxic: Yes.-Chip Resistant: Yes.-Rust Resistant: Yes.-Warp Resistant: Yes.-Non-Stick Surface: No.-Shape: Square.-Foldable: No.-Handles: No -Number of Handles: .-Handle Material: .-Handle Finish: .-Non-Slip Handle: ..-Lid Included: No -Number of Lids: .-Lid Handle: .-Lid Material: .-Lid Finish: ..-Oven Safe: Yes.-Microwave Safe: No.-Dishwasher Safe: Yes.-Insulated: No.-Recommended Utensil Material: Wood; Silicon; Rubber; Plastic; Stainless Steel; Aluminum; Copper.-Recipes Included: No.-Recycled Content: No -Total Recycled Content (Percentage): .-Post-Consumer Content (Percentage): .-Remanufactured/Refurbished: ..-Eco-Friendly: No.-Country of Manufacture: United States.Dimensions: -Overall Height - Top to Bottom: 1.-Overall Width - Side to Side: 12.-Overall Depth - Front to Back: 12.-Overall Product Weight: 2.Assembly: -Assembly Required: No -Tools Needed for Assembly: ..Warranty: -Manufacturer provides lifetime warranty.-Product Warranty: Lifetime. read more

T-Fal
$30.00 $17.99

Ready for an irresistible treat? Bake a batch of your favorite cookies on this Airbake insulated cookie sheet. The layer of air be...tween the two heavyweight aluminum layers ensures your cookies are evenly baked and browned and ready for that glass of cold milk. nonstick surface lets cookies slide right off and makes cleanups easy Micro-Dome technology decreases bake times by up to 15% over traditional insulated bakeware Aluminum. Measures 14x12". Dishwasher safe. Imported. read more

Nonstick

Nonstick coating is available for cookies sheets, but it's not necessary. If recipes are followed and sheets are greased as necessary, the cleanup won't be that much different. Know that sheets with nonstick coating may not have the longevity that uncoated sheets may have.

shop Nonstick
TFX Nonstick!
$29.95

TFX Nonstick! All-In-One Kitchen Full Size Sheets are the convenient and healthy alternative to non-stick cooking. Each reusable n...on-stick full size sheet is designed to fit baking pans up to a size of 16.5 inches by 24.5 inches but you don't have to stop there. Because the TFX Nonstick! baking sheets can be cut to fit any shaped pan. Purchase multiple sheets and cut them to fit every piece of bakeware in your kitchen - round, square or rectangle. Each TFX Nonstick! sheet can be used when baking or in your cook top pans as well. When using on a gas stove, cut your TFX Nonstick! sheet to fit the bottom of the pan so the sheet does not come in contact with an open gas flame. No oil, butter or non-stick spray is needed when cooking, which makes the TFX Nonstick! sheet a healthier cooking alternative. Food will release easily from the sheet. Frying eggs has never been healthier and clean up is a snap. TFX Nonstick! baking sheets can withstand temperatures up to 500 DegreeF or 260 DegreeC. You have 1,000+ opportunities to reuse each TFX Nonstick! baking sheet and it can easily be cleaned with soap, a damp sponge or in the dishwasher. Nothing sticks to the TFX Nonstick! baking sheet and it will not retain odors or flavors. Heat will be transferred evenly when baking and will cost you less than 1 per use and save you clean up time. Do not use sharp instruments on the surface of the sheet, as it may cause scratches or damage the sheet. Avoid folding the sheet to maintain its properties. This is an ideal alternative to parchment paper, wax paper and/or aluminum foil. Sheets can also be used in your microwave, toaster oven or oven as a liner. Do not allow the sheet to cover open holes in the oven or come into direct contact with open flames or heating elements. When looking for a healthier cooking alternative stick to the TFX Nonstick! All-In-One Kitchen Sheet!. read more

Nordic Ware
$32.50

Nordic Ware Nonstick Big Sheet Baking Pan provides 35% larger surface than the half sheet. Make mega batches of cookies & bars... with this extra-large sheet pan featuring a PFOA-free nonstick coating. 21L x 15W x 1H., At Home,Kitchen,Bakeware read more

T-Fal
$60.00 $35.99

Ready for an irresistible treat? Bake a batch of your favorite cookies on these Airbake insulated cookie sheets. The layer of air ...between the two heavyweight aluminum layers ensures your cookies are evenly baked and browned and ready for that glass of cold milk. nonstick surface lets cookies slide right off and makes cleanups easy Micro-Dome technology decreases bake times by up to 15% over traditional insulated bakeware 2-piece set includes: 14x12" cookie sheet 16x14" cookie sheet Aluminum. Hand wash. Imported. read more

Calphalon
$16.00

Find Bakeware And Ovenware at Target.com! The Select by Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Large Loaf Pan is the secret to creating beaut...iful breads, pound cake, meatloaf and more. The durable, nonstick finish allows your baked goods to slide right out for... read more

Insulated Cookie Sheets

Insulated cookie sheets slow baking and tend to yield pale cookies with soft centers. If you bake cookies on an insulated sheet long enough to brown the bottoms, the rest of the cookies will be dry. However, if your oven runs hot or browns cookies. rapidly, insulated cookie sheets may improve results.

shop Insulated Cookie Sheets
Nordicware
$13.99

NWR2036 Features Material: Aluminum Made in the USA Country of Manufacture: United States Color: Silver Material: Aluminum Dimensi...ons Overall Height - Top to Bottom: 1.13'' Overall Width - Side to Side: 16.25'' Overall Depth - Front to Back: 14.25'' Overall Product Weight: 1.95 lbs read more

T-Fal
$60.00 $35.99

Ready for an irresistible treat? Bake a batch of your favorite cookies on these Airbake insulated cookie sheets. The layer of air ...between the two heavyweight aluminum layers ensures your cookies are evenly baked and browned and ready for that glass of cold milk. nonstick surface lets cookies slide right off and makes cleanups easy Micro-Dome technology decreases bake times by up to 15% over traditional insulated bakeware 2-piece set includes: 14x12" cookie sheet 16x14" cookie sheet Aluminum. Hand wash. Imported. read more

Crate and Barrel
$16.95

A commercial-grade essential for every home baker. -Heavy-gauge aluminum -Central air chamber insulates food from excessive heat -...Promotes even baking and browning -Hand wash -Made in China read more

Crate and Barrel
$16.95

A commercial-grade essential for every home baker. - A commercial-grade essential for every home baker. -Heavy-gauge aluminum -Cen...tral air chamber insulates food from excessive heat -Promotes even baking and browning -Hand wash -Made in China read more

Sheet Pan or Jelly Roll Pan

A sheet pan, also known as a jelly roll pan, is a baking sheet with sides about 1 inch high. The sides prevent air from circulating around the cookies perfectly, so this pan is best reserved for baking bar cookies.

shop Sheet Pan or Jelly Roll Pan
Cost Plus World Market
$8.99

Our World Market exclusive commercial-grade nonstick Cookie Sheet makes it easier than ever to outfit your kitchen with the very b...est bakeware at an affordable price. The nonstick coating ensures that your baked goods slide free every time, and makes cleanup a snap. read more

CeramaBake
$13.61

This beautiful bright white bakeware - inside and out - uses an innovative ceramic technology coating that is not only easy-to-cle...an and stain-resistant, but it is also PTFE & PFOA FREE. Aluminized Steel construction offers durability and even heating. CeramaBake is suitable for ANY baking temperature and comes backed by a 5-Year Limited Household Warranty. read more

Nordic Ware
$13.99

Natural aluminum for even baking. Premium gold non-stick interior is especially hard and resistant to scratching. Encapsulated gal...vanized steel rims prevent warping. Each product carries a lifetime warranty. Roast, toast, warm and bake on this standard sized jelly roll pan. Slightly smaller than our half sheet to fit European ovens. read more

Purchase Considerations

Purchase Considerations

When purchasing baking or cookie sheets, buy at least two. Most cookie recipes make more than one sheetful, so for consistency it's best to bake them on the same style of pan. Look for sturdy, heavyweight cookie sheets that won't warp or bend in the oven's heat. When buying new baking or cookie sheets, don't forget add-ons such as baking mats or parchment paper.

Size

Baking and cookie sheets come in a variety of sizes, and it's best to have a couple of large ones and a couple of small ones. If you like to bake cookies, however, you may want more. Make sure when the sheet is placed on the oven rack that there is at least 2 inches around all sides so air will circulate and the cookies will bake properly.

Construction

For generations, cookie sheets made of single-ply tin have been popular. Today, however, many options are available, and those sheets with a heavier construction are good choices, as they offer good heat distribution for even baking and will not warp. Nonstick or not is your choice.

Take Sides

Most baking sheets or cookie sheets have a slightly raised lip on one or two sides of the pan. This lip makes it easy to grip the pan to transfer the cookies in and out of the oven.

shop Take Sides
Nordic Ware
$13.70

Nordic Ware Hi-Side Sheet Cake Baking Pan with Lid With 2 high sides for bakery-sized sheet cakes. Super for double recipes of des...serts, bars and brownies. Features: -Material: Aluminum.-Hand wash recommended.-Comes with BPA-free plastic cover.-Made in... read more

Paderno World Cuisine
$44.90

This 25 1/2 long by 17 3/4 wide by 1 1/8 high splayed sided (3 cm) aluminized steel baking sheet is suited for baking and browning... large, dense dough products. The sheet allows for full exposure to the heat of the oven. read more

Paderno World Cuisine
$64.65

This 23 5/8 long by 15 3/4 wide straight sided aluminum baking sheet has shallow, flared edges for baking and browning large, dens...e dough products. The sheet allows for full exposure to the heat of the oven. read more

Kaisercraft
$13.37

Silly Season Double Sided Paper 12-inch by 12-inch Milk and cookies Fits Christmas BTP 10 sheets of paper. Silly season double sid...ed paper 12-inch by 12-inch. Kaisercraft silly season collection. this package contains ten 12x12 inch sheets of double sided scrapbook paper. available in a variety of silly season designs: each sold separately. photo friendly. made in usa.. Product name: milk and cookies fits christmas btp 10 sheets. read more

Not to Be Confused

A baking sheet or cookie sheet should not be confused with a sheet pan (jelly roll pan). While a baking or cookie sheet typically has an upturned lip, a sheet pan or jelly roll pan is a baking sheet with sides about 1 inch high. These pans are used for bar cookies, brownies, and sheet cakes.

Baking Mats

Baking mats keep cookies and other baked goods from sticking to the pan's surface. Made of silicone, fiberglass, or other materials, these mats are reusable and also resistant to high heat. If you don't have baking mats, you can use parchment paper to keep cookies from sticking.

shop Baking Mats
Crate and Barrel
$14.95

Used in place of parchment to help prevent sticking or burning, this flexible modern baking mat of silicone-coated fiberglass turn...s any cutting surface or pan into an easy-release, non-stick surface for dough prep and baking. Mat may be placed directly... read more

Crate and Barrel
$14.95

Used in place of parchment to help prevent sticking or burning, this flexible modern baking mat of silicone-coated fiberglass turn...s any cutting surface or pan into an easy-release, non-stick surface for dough prep and baking. Mat may be placed directly... read more

$24.99

As much a cooking utensil as it is a baking sheet liner, Lekue's nonstick baking mat allows for optimal heat distribution in a sho...rter cooking time. read more

Tovolo
$18.00

No more greasing and no more burning! this baking mat's silicone fiber insulates your pan and provides a non-stick surface. Bake o...n it, wipe it down, and then roll it up for easy storage. This cookie sheet measures 13.5" X 14.5". read more

Kitchen on sale

T-Fal
$60.00 $35.99

Ready for an irresistible treat? Bake a batch of your favorite cookies on these Airbake insulated cookie sheets. The layer of air ...between the two heavyweight aluminum layers ensures your cookies are evenly baked and browned and ready for that glass of cold milk. nonstick surface lets cookies slide right off and makes cleanups easy Micro-Dome technology decreases bake times by up to 15% over traditional insulated bakeware 2-piece set includes: 14x12" cookie sheet 16x14" cookie sheet Aluminum. Hand wash. Imported. read more

Berghoff
$72.00 $42.99

This cookie sheet is more than just quality bakewareit's also part of a convenient cutting system. The unique patented guideline g...rid around the outer edges of the pan allows you to simply line up an exclusive PerfectSlice cutting tool, and press down to create any portion size desired. every slice is beautifully uniform high-impact polystyrene cutting tool with silicone handle is tough enough to cut your treat yet won't damage your pan heavy-duty nonstick carbon steel won't chip oven safe up to 450F Carbon steel/polystyrene/silicone. Dishwasher safe. Imported. read more

Farberware
$34.00 $20.99

Save time by baking a large batch of cookies at once with the durable Farberware Insulated Nonstick Bakeware 15-1/2-Inch x 20-Inch... Jumbo Cookie Sheet. With double pan layers enclosing a pocket of air that heats and circulates during baking, every piece of Farberware Insulated Bakeware promotes beautiful browning and baking results. This large cookie sheet boasts durable, heavy-duty carbon steel construction that resists warping, even when baking batch after batch of chewy double chocolate fudge cookies or crispy butterscotch biscotti. And featuring a distinctive two-level pan surface that creates insulated, heated airflow, the generous cookie pan provides even baking and browning. Top-quality nonstick and a rimless pan edge allow baked goods to easily slide to a cooling rack, and make cleanup quick. Oven safe to 450 degrees F, this nonstick cookie sheet is an ideal complement to the baking sets and other pans in the Farberware Insulated Bakeware collection. Create two dozen delicious cookies at once with the generous capacity of the Farberware Insulated Nonstick Bakeware 15-1/2-Inch x 20-Inch Jumbo Cookie Sheet. read more

Farberware
$30.00 $16.49

Save time by baking a large batch of cookies at once with the durable Farberware Insulated Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch x 16-Inch Coo...kie Sheet. With double pan layers enclosing a pocket of air that heats and circulates during baking, every piece of Farberware Insulated Bakeware promotes beautiful browning and baking results. This large cookie sheet boasts durable, heavy-duty carbon steel construction that resists warping, even when baking batch after batch of chewy double chocolate fudge cookies or crispy butterscotch biscotti. And featuring a distinctive two-level pan surface that creates insulated, heated airflow, the generous cookie pan provides even baking and browning. Top-quality nonstick and a rimless pan edge allow baked goods to easily slide to a cooling rack, and make cleanup quick. Oven safe to 450 degrees F, this nonstick cookie sheet is an ideal complement to the baking sets and other pans in the Farberware Insulated Bakeware collection. Create a large batch of delicious cookies at once with the generous capacity of the Farberware Insulated Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch x 16-Inch Cookie Sheet. read more

Farberware
$18.00 $9.99

For consistency and ease of baking, consider buying two cookie pans of the same type. Matching pans helps produce a uniform batch ...of cookies and allows you to keep one pan in the oven while you're cooling the other, thus speeding the baking process. made of heavyweight carbon steel to aid in even browning nonstick surface makes cleanup easy and allows you to bake cookies without greasing the pan shallow lip around the edge of the pan makes it suitable for jobs beyond cookie baking, such as roasting vegetables oven safe to 500F Carbon steel. Hand wash. Imported. read more

USA PAN
$32.00 $18.99

Now you can fit more cookies on this larger-sized sheet, eliminating the need to bake multiple batches. Cookies slide right off th...e nonstick, coated surface with the use of a spatula, and the lipped edge makes it easy to hold. heavy-gauge aluminized steel construction nonstick silicone coating ridged bottom lip on one side Aluminized steel. Measures 18x14". Hand wash. PTFE- and PFOA-free. Made in America. read more

Nordicware
$37.00 $21.99

From snickerdoodles to classic chocolate chip, this cookie sheet helps you turn out large batches of evenly cooked, delicious cook...ies every time. commercial-quality, heavy cast aluminum construction premium nonstick interior provides ultra-smooth release large surface area fits in most standard ovens Aluminum. Measures 21x15". Hand wash. Made in America. read more

Farberware
$29.00 $16.99

Speed up the baking process with a Farberware jumbo cookie sheet. oversized to bake more cookies at one time nonstick coating requ...ires no greasing and cleans up easily insulated to disperse heat for more even browning 15��x20x��"H. Dishwasher-safe and imported. read more

USA PAN
$30.00 $17.99

You'll enjoy baking more than ever with this heavy-duty, nonstick cookie sheet featuring a ridged, nonstick surface with an elevat...ed lip on one side. heavy-gauge aluminized steel construction nonstick silicone coating ridged bottom lip on one side Aluminized steel. Measures 14x14". Hand wash. PTFE- and PFOA-free. Made in America. read more

T-Fal
$36.00 $19.99

Ready for an irresistible treat? Bake a batch of your favorite cookies on this Airbake insulated cookie sheet. The layer of air be...tween the two heavyweight aluminum layers ensures your cookies are evenly baked and browned and ready for that glass of cold milk. nonstick surface lets cookies slide right off and makes cleanups easy Micro-Dome technology decreases bake times by up to 15% over traditional insulated bakeware Aluminum. Measures 16x14". Dishwasher safe. Imported. read more

This item has been added to your list

This item has been added to your sale alerts