Baking and Cookie Sheets Buying Guide

Refine By

A batch of warm homemade cookies is a sure hit with family and friends. Know that the baking or cookie sheets you use can affect the results of your fresh-baked goodies. Cookie sheets come in several materials, including metal, aluminum, aluminized steel, and more, and they range in quality as well as price.

Types of Baking and Cookie Sheets

Types of Baking and Cookie Sheets

The terms baking sheet and cookie sheet are really the same. They are flat pans that allow heat to circulate around the cookies and make for easy removal. The type of material and finish you choose for cookie sheets affects the final product. Shiny bakeware reflects heat, slowing the browning process; dark- and dull-finish bakeware absorbs more heat, which increases browning.

Metal

Cookie sheets are commonly made of tin, aluminum, aluminized steel, and other metals. Construction ranges from single-ply tin to heavy-duty pans composed of multiple layers with an aluminum core.

shop Metal
Calphalon
$32.99

More durable than traditional metal bakeware, Calphalon's ceramic nonstick finish delivers high release performance and is PFOA- a...nd PTFE-free. Baking sheet features a sparkling rich black finish that's also scratch-resistant.View all Calphalon... read more

Calphalon
$72.00 $39.99

Cook and cool with this baker's set from Calphalon. Cookie sheets are made of aluminum with heavy-gauge steel cores to heat evenly.... Cooling racks fit neatly over the pans and allow baked goods to cool off quickly and evenly.View all Calphalon products... read more

Crate&Barrel
$34.95

Coated on the interior with a proprietary ceramic coating, these aluminized steel baking sheets easily release baked goods time af...ter time. Set includes: one 11"x17" and one 10"x15" cookie sheet. \u2022 Aluminized steel with Fusion r ceramic coating... read more

USA Pan
$19.99

Our commercial-quality bakeware features a unique textured surface that promotes ideal air circulation and a double-duty nonstick ...Americoat and silicone glaze finish for clean food release. Durable folded construction with heavy-gauge wire is... read more

Finish

Cookies bake more evenly on light- to medium-color cookie sheets, whether the sheets are shiny or nonstick. When baked on dark sheets, cookie bottoms tend to overbrown.

shop Finish
Iris USA Inc
$24.99

Bake your favorite recipes with this medium-sized cookie sheet. Made from steel and coated with two layers of ceramic, the sheet o...ffers even heat distribution and hassle-free cleanup. Material: Aluminum Set Includes: 1 Piece Shape: Rectangle Type:... read more

T-Fal
$17.59

Find Bakeware and Cookware at Target.com! AirBake brand has always been "The Original Insulated Bakeware". AirBake continues to pr...ovide the best baking results every time. AirBake Nonstick provides an overall enhanced baking performance with its insulated aluminum sheets and micro-dome technology to decrease bake times by up to 15 percent over traditional insulated bakeware. Two heavyweight aluminum steel sheets with a nonstick surface surround a layer of air. The air reduces the temperature of the metal that comes in contact with the food. The bottom sheet blocks the direct oven heat while the layer of air acts as an insulator preventing the top sheet from overheating. This means better browning, no burning, and moister baked goods. Insulated bakeware means cookies won't burn and the nonstick surface means clean-up is a breeze. Set includes medium cookie sheet 14-inches x 12-inches and Large cookie sheet 16-inches x 14-inches Color: Medium Silver. read more

Wilton Bakeware
$20.00 $9.99

Wilton Bakeware Pro Medium Cookie Sheet. Bake your favorite foods like a professional with this medium cookie sheet! Featuring Dur...amax non-stick coating, this pan feels noticeably heavier than most comparable brands, assuring you that this must-have bakeware heats evenly every time. read more

Nonstick

Nonstick coating is available for cookies sheets, but it's not necessary. If recipes are followed and sheets are greased as necessary, the cleanup won't be that much different. Know that sheets with nonstick coating may not have the longevity that uncoated sheets may have.

shop Nonstick
casaWare
$18.32

The casaWare Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan is perfect for cookies, jelly roll cakes and other tasty treats! This pan has two nonstick cera...mic coatings that make it both durable and easy to clean. The cream colored ceramic nonstick baking surface is PTFE Free,... read more

casaWare
$16.32

The casaWare Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan is perfect for cookies, jelly roll cakes and other tasty treats! This pan has two nonstick cera...mic coatings that make it both durable and easy to clean. The cream colored ceramic nonstick baking surface is PTFE Free,... read more

casaWare
$16.32

The casaWare Excel Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan is perfect for cookies, jelly roll cakes and other tasty treats! 1-inch Handles for Easy ...Gripping. Heavier weight, Durable 0.6mm Thickness. This pan has two nonstick ceramic coatings that make it both durable... read more

casaWare
$15.99

The casaWare Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan is perfect for cookies, jelly roll cakes and other tasty treats! This pan has two nonstick cera...mic coatings that make it both durable and easy to clean. The cream colored ceramic nonstick baking surface is PTFE Free,... read more

Insulated Cookie Sheets

Insulated cookie sheets slow baking and tend to yield pale cookies with soft centers. If you bake cookies on an insulated sheet long enough to brown the bottoms, the rest of the cookies will be dry. However, if your oven runs hot or browns cookies. rapidly, insulated cookie sheets may improve results.

shop Insulated Cookie Sheets
Calphalon
$37.99

Your search for the perfect cookie stops here. This large pan creates chewy, never dry or burned, treats that delight and take you... right back to grandma's secret recipe. Two interlocking layers of high-performance nonstick coupled with an innovative insulated design create a barrier that slows down the cooking process for perfectly golden cookies and ensures cookies are released with ease from the pan. Lifetime warranty. read more

Fox Run Craftsmen
$37.00 $19.83

Baking Sheets Non-Stick Air Insulated Cookie Sheet

Wilton
$32.99

Baking Sheets Non-Stick Air Insulated Cookie Sheet

Sheet Pan or Jelly Roll Pan

A sheet pan, also known as a jelly roll pan, is a baking sheet with sides about 1 inch high. The sides prevent air from circulating around the cookies perfectly, so this pan is best reserved for baking bar cookies.

shop Sheet Pan or Jelly Roll Pan
Wilton
$7.99

Find Bakeware and Ovenware at Target.com! Silicone Jelly Roll Pan Equally as impressive as it is delicious, a simple jelly roll ca...ke is a party favorite. This flexible Silicone Jelly Roll Pan makes it easy to transform your thin layer of cake into a classic Swiss roll. Oven safe to 450°F silicone is also microwave and freezer safe. Dishwasher safe for fast and easy cleanup, too. Bake a your favorite chocolate or Swiss roll cake recipe with this easy-to-use Silicone Jelly Roll Pan Oven safe, flexible silicone makes it easy to roll your cake into the perfect jelly roll cake shape Simply roll the flexible silicone pan as you shape your cake; unroll to ice and reroll for pure perfection Silicone jelly roll pan is oven-safe to 450°F and microwave and freezer safe for added versatility Dishwasher safe for fast and easy cleanup Color: Aqua. read more

USA Pans
$19.93

The USA Pans Small Jellyroll Pan is constructed of aluminized steel, the material of choice for commercial bakeries. Jellyroll pan...s are a standard for many bakers. The large baking surface and raised walls are ideal for baking everything from drop... read more

Nordic Ware
$13.49

Standard jelly roll pan size, which is slightly smaller than our half sheet. Fits European sized ovens. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan...: For baked veggies, french fries, muffins, cookies, cakes and more Standard jelly roll pan size Made out of aluminum... read more

OXO
$24.99

OXO Good Grips Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan. Experience the exceptional durability and quality performance of this jelly roll pan! This... must-have piece's micro-textured surface heats evenly while the non-stick coating allows for easy release. read more

Purchase Considerations

Purchase Considerations

When purchasing baking or cookie sheets, buy at least two. Most cookie recipes make more than one sheetful, so for consistency it's best to bake them on the same style of pan. Look for sturdy, heavyweight cookie sheets that won't warp or bend in the oven's heat. When buying new baking or cookie sheets, don't forget add-ons such as baking mats or parchment paper.

Size

Baking and cookie sheets come in a variety of sizes, and it's best to have a couple of large ones and a couple of small ones. If you like to bake cookies, however, you may want more. Make sure when the sheet is placed on the oven rack that there is at least 2 inches around all sides so air will circulate and the cookies will bake properly.

Construction

For generations, cookie sheets made of single-ply tin have been popular. Today, however, many options are available, and those sheets with a heavier construction are good choices, as they offer good heat distribution for even baking and will not warp. Nonstick or not is your choice.

Take Sides

Most baking sheets or cookie sheets have a slightly raised lip on one or two sides of the pan. This lip makes it easy to grip the pan to transfer the cookies in and out of the oven.

shop Take Sides
Paderno World Cuisine
$107.10

For over 80 years, Paderno (Italy) has been a leading company in the manufacturing of professional cookware and kitchen utensils. ...The company is constantly engaged in enhancing the quality of its products and consistently complies with the most recent... read more

Paderno
$87.99

The Paderno Nonstick Baking Sheet with Angled Sides is a durable nonstick sheet that is suitable for standard baked goods, such as... pastries and confections. This aluminum, silicone-coated sheet will be welcome in any baker's kitchen. read more

Paderno World Cuisine
$96.80

For over 80 years, Paderno (Italy) has been a leading company in the manufacturing of professional cookware and kitchen utensils. ...The company is constantly engaged in enhancing the quality of its products and consistently complies with the most recent... read more

Paderno World Cuisine
$157.05

For over 80 years, Paderno (Italy) has been a leading company in the manufacturing of professional cookware and kitchen utensils. ...The company is constantly engaged in enhancing the quality of its products and consistently complies with the most recent... read more

Not to Be Confused

A baking sheet or cookie sheet should not be confused with a sheet pan (jelly roll pan). While a baking or cookie sheet typically has an upturned lip, a sheet pan or jelly roll pan is a baking sheet with sides about 1 inch high. These pans are used for bar cookies, brownies, and sheet cakes.

Baking Mats

Baking mats keep cookies and other baked goods from sticking to the pan's surface. Made of silicone, fiberglass, or other materials, these mats are reusable and also resistant to high heat. If you don't have baking mats, you can use parchment paper to keep cookies from sticking.

shop Baking Mats
The PhatMat
$22.59 $21.94

Silicone baking sheets for healthy lifestyle from The PhatMat the healthy alternative! Are you worried about baking with Teflon pa...ns, oils, grease and spray chemicals? Do you want a healthy non-stick option? Are you spending too much money for parchment paper, wax paper, sprays and oils? Are you tired of wasting time scrubbing and cleaning pans and floured counters.do what the professional chef’s do introducing The PhatMat nonstick baking sheet. BPA free food-safe silicone mat won't stick to foods. Premium materials means no funny added tastes. Easy to clean with warm water and mild soap. Dishwasher safe! Reusable matt will save you money over expensive papers, sprays and oils! Multi-purpose. Use for kneading dough, crafts as well! Stop filling landfills with used paper and spray products.16 1/8 x 11 1/4 inches fit half sheet cookie sheets. FDA & LFGB approved combo includes our special PFOA free nonstick griller. On-stick reusable fiberglass/silicone grill mesh keeps food off dirty grill grates. No char or aluminum. Healthy alternative. Extra thick material - last a long time. Open mesh allows smoke flavor to penetrate food. Fish and vegetables will not stick or fall through grate. Storage tube for safe mat storage. Amazon buyers trust The PhatMat brand to be highest quality product. read more

Sur La Table
$26.95

This nonstick silicone mat provides even heat transfer and ensures that cooked foods release easily. Constructed from durable food...-grade silicone reinforced with a flexible glass weave, Silpat baking mats are effective in temperatures ranging from -40°F to 500°F. Designed to fit the popular 18-by-14-inch cookie sheet pan.Silpat mats sold individually, not as a set. read more

Winco
$29.99

Baking Sheets Silicone Baking Mat

Fox Run Craftsmen
$14.63

Baking Sheets Baking Mat

Kitchen on sale

Calphalon
$72.00 $39.99

Cook and cool with this baker's set from Calphalon. Cookie sheets are made of aluminum with heavy-gauge steel cores to heat evenly.... Cooling racks fit neatly over the pans and allow baked goods to cool off quickly and evenly.View all Calphalon products... read more

Cuisinart
$50.00 $23.95

The bakeware collection from Cuisinart delivers the same quality construction and performance you expect from their cookware, with... the convenience of a premium professional nonstick finish that pops baked goods right out of this raised-rim baking... read more

USA Pan
$32.95 $29.99

Made in the USA, this half baking sheet is constructed of heavy-gauge steel for even heat distribution and extreme durability. The... pan's fluted surface design maximizes pan strength and facilitates air circulation for an evenly baked product that... read more

Rachael Ray
$39.99 $19.99

Help give your oven fries and baked chicken a boost with Rachael Ray's Cucina 2-piece baking sheet and crisper set. A perforated i...nset helps heat circulate around food, promoting crisper results. read more

Rachael Ray
$33.99 $16.99

Roast, toast or bake to perfection with this 11 x 17 Rachael Ray Cucina cookie sheet, featuring a non-stick surface that helps you... get great results every time. read more

Cuisinart
$30.00 $14.99

The baker's best! Showoff your gourmet skills with this heavy-gauge aluminized steel baking sheet, which heats evenly and features... a nonstick finish that knows when to let go & how to clean up quick & easy. A dishwasher-safe design eliminates any... read more

Calphalon
$37.99 $24.99

Your search for the perfect cookie stops here. This large pan creates chewy, never dry or burned, treats that delight and take you... right back to grandma's secret recipe. Two interlocking layers of high-performance nonstick coupled with an innovative... read more

Calphalon
$29.99 $19.99

Baked goods on a roll? Not anymore! This heavy-gauge steel pan keeps your jelly rolls, strudels and calzones in place, so juices a...nd fillings never spill out and presentation is always mouthwateringly delicious. Two interlocking layers of professional... read more

Calphalon
$40.99 $26.99

... and your kitchen is stocked! This set includes the baker's best-a baking sheet and brownie pan, both with heavy-gauge steel co...res that heat up quickly & evenly. It's easy to fill your space with cookies, jelly rolls, brownies, mini cakes and more... read more

Calphalon
$29.99 $19.99

Welcome to a world of baked greats! Perfect for cookies, dinner rolls, pastries and beyond, this large cookie sheet features two u...pturned ends for easy lifting and open sides, so food slides right off. Crafted with a heavy-gauge steel core for even... read more

Products at Walmart
Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate
Bouquets from FTD

This item has been added to your list

This item has been added to your sale alerts