Turn a box into a puzzle-themed pencil holder.
1. Buy a decorative box or spruce up a cardboard box with craft paint. Dip a pencil eraser in green paint to make the polka dots.
2. On your computer, make a May Day label in the shape of a crossword puzzle.
3. Fill the box with crayons, games, cards, jacks, and marbles -- whatever brainteasers will keep the recipient puzzled for hours.