Cookie Exchange Favorites
These gorgeous and delicious Christmas cookies will impress your friends and family. Bonus: Every recipe here is a snap to make -- they'll only think you spent hours baking.
- Share
- Comments (22)
- view all thumbnails
Think itty-bitty when it comes to sharing Christmas cookies. These peppermint delights are just larger than the hard candy that inspired them.
A crunchy-sweet swirl of mixed nuts, brown sugar, and cinnamon dresses up basic cookie dough. Vanilla glaze adds a festive holiday touch.
The rich, gooey filling in these tarts has a hit of raspberry liqueur.
Cream cheese gives these almond-studded, slice-and-bake cookies moistness and richness.
These buttery, powdered sugar-dusted crescents feature delicate vanilla flavor.
A browned-butter drizzle takes these super-simple cookies to the next level.
These little cookie sandwiches perfectly balance spicy and sweet. Basic cookie dough is spiked with chipotle chili pepper, while a fluffy chocolate filling adds sweetness.
Press balls of espresso cookie dough into mini muffin cups, then fill with luscious spiced chocolate. A decadent espresso-chocolate ganache makes a festive finishing touch.
Love the zing of Red Hots? Crushed and mixed with sugar, they become a crunchy topper for these biscotti-like cookies.
Coarse sugar gives these lightly spiced cookies a touch of holiday sparkle.
To make these lovely no-bake treats, freeze the dough balls on sticks, then dip them in a melted chocolate mixture.
Dried cranberries and lemon peel add zing to these festive little cookies.
These buttery cookies feature all the delicious flavors of the popular Christmas cocktail. Melted white chocolate and a dusting of nutmeg make a pretty finishing touch.
Melted white chocolate and crushed pistachio nuts dress up simple shortbread cookies.
You can't go wrong with this classic Christmas cookie. Sprinkle on coarse sugar for a bit of holiday cheer.
Featuring the delicious flavors of two classic holiday desserts, this crowd-pleasing cookie makes an ideal gift.
Layered chocolate-mint candies add pizzazz to this classic chocolate chip cookie recipe.
Chocolate-covered peanut butter cups nestle inside peanut butter cookies for a happy surprise. A sprinkling of cocoa powder adds extra chocolaty goodness.
A pretty flower pattern dresses up these easy-to-make, pumpkin-spiced cookies.
Dry-roasted cashews add a salty spin to classic butterscotch-chip cookies.
These sophisticated treats feature a cashew shortbread base and a luscious caramel filling.
Topped with grated nutmeg and finely chopped macadamia nuts, these pretty cookies are a treat to eat.
These moist cookies combine three favorites -- chocolate, peanut butter, and banana -- and they use just four ingredients. Add an extra festive touch by decorating them with red coarse sugar.
Powdered sugar makes a simple topping for these tender, minty butter cookies.
Wrap four or five of these simple macaroons in red cellophane, tie each bundle with silver ribbon, and give them out as gifts.
Lemon peel adds fresh flavor to these whole wheat cranberry cookies.
Red coarse sugar jazzes up these almond-filled, sugary sliced cookies.






I made these this year (2011). Every year I try to add a new cookie to my cookie list of favorites and this is it!!! delicious and perfect for mailing. Love Love Love these!!!
12/23/2011 10:27:17 AM Report AbuseAgree with just tinker post above....something is DEFINATELY missing from that cookie recipe...I have heard of putting the can of dulce de leche in a pot of boiling water for hours to thicken and cook it...I've never done it, but maybe that is the missing step? I sure hope nobody went to all the trouble of trying to make them before finding the mistake.....
12/21/2011 10:20:23 PM Report AbuseFor the person who wanted a recipe for Pink Meringue Clouds, go to Food.com. They have an excellent recipe for this cookie.
12/16/2011 12:10:12 AM Report AbuseI don't like the way the site is set up either. I only come here if I see something that REALLY piques my interest. I could go into more detail, but don't push page clicks over being reader friendly. You WILL lose readers that way. We want to click once, MAYBE twice, and get the info we came for. Nuff said?
12/13/2011 12:39:35 PM Report AbuseFor those of you who wanted a list,; if you click on the little tab in the upper righthand corner that says view all thumbnails, you can see all of them instead of going through the whole slide show.
12/10/2011 01:55:02 PM Report AbuseI second the thoughts that it's awfully cumbersome trying to look at the recipes and that exchange cookies need to be exchange friendly.
12/10/2011 09:13:09 AM Report AbuseMerry Christmas! Get your free Christmas Gift Now! ( ==== http://www.vogue7.us/ ==== )Online Store,Get Name Brand Fashion From 12USD Now! Hand-bag price is$35Polo,Locaste,Levis,EdHardy,Bape,Christan Audigier AF,COOGI Tshirt price is $12 Bikini $15 sunglasses (Dior,Armaini)$16 Bikini ( Polo,Gucci,LV, ) $15 Accept Credit card payment , Western Union and electronic bank transferFree shipping.Door to Door services!5 days arrive your home or youur friends? adress by EMS,DHL,UPS
12/9/2011 12:38:13 PM Report AbuseMy mother used to make a cookie for cookie exchanges called Pink Meringue Clouds, they are so perfect for Christmas time, a sugar cookie topped with a peppermint meringue dollop with chocolate chips in it...would anyone happen to have that recipe?
12/8/2011 07:01:34 PM Report AbuseEditors: To consider next year.-Cookie exchange recipes are high yield 48-72 cookies per batch, easy to prepare, pack and freeze. Hold up well in transit without fear of sticking together or breaking apart. Look great on a plate, mouth watering and most importantly, the recipe everyone will ask for.
12/7/2011 09:53:00 AM Report AbuseKeep hoping to see some Gluten free goodies for those of us who are restricted. : )
12/6/2011 01:14:16 PM Report AbuseI just wish I could get ANYTHING TO SHOW UP on this site!!! Very frustrating!!! I have even tryed to hit on "view all thumbnails" and get nothing but an empty box.!!! Kathy
11/24/2011 08:13:08 PM Report AbuseIn the picture of your Alfajores cookies the filling is brown and thick....the dulce de leche that is carries in the stores is white and runny...perhaps part of the recipe is missing?
11/17/2011 07:32:00 AM Report AbuseWould be nice to see original ideas instead of the same cookies over and over with different catchy titles, so that you get excited and click on it, only to see the same cookies as last year and the year before. Just saying...
11/16/2011 01:26:06 PM Report AbuseI have been making these cookies for 20 years. I now use 1/4 cup of oil and 1/4 butter. I also use an additional 4 ounces of bittersweet chocolate. When I make these for my chocoholic friends, I also add 1 cup of chocolate chips. Yummmm
11/15/2011 01:10:34 PM Report AbuseI have to say that I wonder if the person who assembled this list actually attends cookie exchanges. The chocolate cookie with the cherry stems sticking out...how well does that keep? Plus how do you pack it by the dozen for distribution? It looks like it would not stack well. Cookies for cookie exchanges..must be easily packaged and may sometimes be packed a day or two ahead or baked and frozen ahead of time. Remember, we could be making 12 or more dozen at a time.
11/14/2011 11:19:24 AM Report AbuseI agree with WendyOakford above. I would appreciate a list of the recipes so I can just look at what interests me. It really is frustrating. I have difficulty going back to the next item, if I print out a recipe. KuiipoOmaha
11/13/2011 04:19:58 PM Report AbuseCan I just get a list of what's on the site rather than read through the entire slide show? I want to see something new, and not the old stuff, or hunt for particular recipes. Help! I don't have much time to peruse the pages, and would still love to be able to see the good ideas I have time to see.
11/9/2011 08:55:40 PM Report AbuseI love all the cookie receipes but wish you would include a discription if it is a crisp cookie, soft cookie, crisp on edges and soft in the middle, etc.. Thanks so much.
10/18/2011 02:52:42 PM Report AbuseSorry for all the frustrations BHG fans! We're always looking for ways to improve the website and improve your experience at BHG.com so your feedback is appreciated. Please know that we read these comments and take them into account when making improvements and updates to the site.
12/2/2010 10:43:45 AM Report AbuseQuestion. How does wheat flour differ from white flour in baking cookies?
11/2/2010 05:43:29 PM Report Abuse