Ask Better Homes & Gardens

Experts and BHG readers answer.

Boxed in vegetable garden

"We recently moved from Fla. to S.C. We want to plant a vegetable garden. The ground is HARD clay. So we plan to box in an area, bring in fill dirt, plus fertilizers etc. What type of wood should we use? We want durability and something ecomonical. Also, should we dig up the clay base any first? Thanks "
Submitted by BHGPhotoContest

"Raised beds of any type should be constructed out of rot resistant materials. Pressure treated lumber is usually the least expensive route to go, but some have concerns about the  treated products leaching into the soil. You  could line the wall of the bed with heavy plastic if this is a concern for you.
Other rot-resistant woods to consider are cedar and redwood. Costs of these vary from region to region, so you may want to check prices of what is available in your area. Other materials to consider are composite lumbers made from a combination of vinyl and wood fibers. These usually are more expensive, but will last longer than wood. In our own Test Garden, the cedar wood raised beds are rotting away after 10 years, but the ones built of composite materials show no signs of rot or decay.

If you make the raised beds deep enough, it isn't necessary to till up the underlying clay. However, mixing in some of the new soil with the existing clay can help prevent the formation of a soil texture barrier through which roots and water won't easily penetrate. The rooting depth for most vegetables should be at least a foot."

Community Answers


Answer this Question

Enter an Answer to this Question

500 characters left